Best overall
AeroPress
AeroPress Coffee Maker - Original
9.0Excellent
The $40 cult brewer: a forgiving, nearly indestructible press that makes a clean cup or espresso-style concentrate in two minutes.
Brewers3$39.95
Keurig
K-Supreme Plus Single Serve Coffee Maker
Keurig's best-equipped non-smart K-Cup brewer: five sizes, strength and temperature control, over-ice mode and three saved profiles.
7.3
Good
Coffee Reviews score
See the breakdown →
Community
—/10
- Type
- Single-serve pod coffee maker (K-Cup)
- Pod system
- K-Cup pods
- Brew sizes
- 4, 6, 8, 10 and 12 oz
- Typical price
- $219.99
We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page. It never affects our scores or what we recommend. How we make money
Last reviewed October 17, 2026 by the Coffee Reviews editors · How we score
Keurig's best-equipped non-smart K-Cup brewer: five sizes, strength and temperature control, over-ice mode and three saved profiles.
The K-Supreme Plus is a single-serve K-Cup brewer with Keurig's MultiStream needles, five cup sizes from 4 to 12 oz, three strength and three temperature settings, an Over Ice button, and three programmable user profiles. Its 78 oz removable reservoir makes up to nine cups between refills. It suits households that value speed and per-person settings over cup quality. Coffee enthusiasts still find pod coffee weak, and Keurig.com was selling it for $99.99 (list $219.99) when checked.
Best for
- Busy households that want a fast single cup with zero cleanup
- Homes where several people each want their own saved settings
- Iced-coffee drinkers who want a dedicated over-ice mode
What we like
- Five cup sizes with three strength and three temperature settings
- Over Ice mode and three programmable user profiles
- 78 oz removable reservoir covers up to nine cups between refills
- Fast, mess-free single cups with no grinding or rinsing
Watch-outs
- Pod coffee is weaker and less nuanced than fresh-ground brewing
- Handle needs 4.7 in of extra clearance, so you may need to slide it out from under cabinets
- Older My K-Cup reusable filters don't fit, according to a reviewer
- Only a limited 1-year warranty
How it scored
The breakdown.
7.3Good
Gear score out of 10, weighted across five factors.
- Performance30%6.9
Keurig says MultiStream extracts more flavor than its K-Classic, and reviewers like the Strong setting, but pod coffee is still weaker than fresh-ground brewing. One reviewer measured about 190°F peak and roughly 170°F in the cup.
- Build & reliability20%7.0
It has a stainless steel wrap over a plastic body and a limited 1-year warranty. Keurig specialist Brian Mounts, who owns every current model, calls the top-line Keurigs well made.
- Ease of use15%8.8
Pod in, button press, cup in about 90 seconds. Three saved profiles, a 78 oz reservoir and an Over Ice button make it among the easiest machines here.
- Value20%7.3
The .99 list price is steep, but Keurig.com was selling it for .99 when checked, and K-Cup boxes start at .99 for 20–24 pods.
- Community love15%7.3
Keurig-focused reviewer Brian Mounts names it his favorite Keurig, but coffee enthusiasts on forums routinely dismiss K-Cup coffee as weak.
Creator video reviews
Watch it in action.
2 positive1 mixed
Independent creators, verified with YouTube and TikTok. We don’t pay for reviews and creators don’t pay us.
What people are saying
From the forums.
Verbatim from Reddit, forums and long-term owner write-ups — linked so you can read the full thread.
“My favorite is the Keurig K-Supreme Plus but there’s a good argument to make that the Duo Plus and the K-Café are the best models too…”
“Keurig is really convenient and cheap. … there is usually less than 10g coffee in each pod (and that varies) and can be really weak for the amount of water used. This is why people suggest that if you have to use Keurig, use the least amount of water allowed.”
“To me Nespresso tastes like actual espresso, Keurig is pretty trashy unless you get really high-end pods.”
Specifications
By the numbers.
- Model
- K-Supreme Plus
- Pod system
- K-Cup pods
- Brew sizes
- 4, 6, 8, 10 and 12 oz
- Reservoir
- 78 oz, removable (up to 9 cups between refills)
- Extraction
- MultiStream Technology
- Customization
- 3 strength and 3 temperature settings
- Iced
- Over Ice button for brewing hot over ice
- Programmable favorites
- Saves size, strength and temperature for up to 3 users
- Mug clearance
- 6.2 in with drip tray, 7.2 in without
- Handle clearance
- Adds 4.7 in of height when opened
- Other modes
- High-altitude brewing mode; descale reminder
- Dimensions
- 12.2 × 8.3 × 13.3 in (H × W × D)
- Warranty
- Limited 1-year
- Brews
- Pod machine, Iced / over ice
- Typical price
- $219.99 for Single-serve brewer (list price; $99.99 site deal on keurig.com when checked) (checked October 2026)
Community
Member tasting notes & discussion.
—
0 member ratings
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Discussion
No discussions yet.
Own Keurig K-Supreme Plus Single Serve Coffee Maker? Ask a question or share your recipe — you’ll be the first.
FAQ
Good questions.
Can the K-Supreme Plus brew iced coffee?
Yes. Keurig's guide says to fill a large plastic tumbler with ice, insert any K-Cup pod, press the OVER ICE button and then brew. Keurig describes the setting as brewing hot over ice for refreshing iced coffee.
What do the strength, temperature and profile buttons do?
You can pick one of three strength and three temperature levels for each brew. Pressing and holding one of the three user-profile buttons saves your size, strength and temperature combination for one-touch brewing.
Can I use my own ground coffee?
Yes, with a reusable My K-Cup filter that fits Keurig's MultiStream needles. Reviewers note that older reusable filters from earlier Keurigs don't fit this machine.
Will it fit under my kitchen cabinets?
Keurig lists it at 12.2 in tall, and opening the handle needs another 4.7 in. One reviewer has to slide it forward each time they load a pod so the handle clears the cabinets.
Sources (10)
- keurig.com/K-Supreme-Plus%C2%AE-Single-Serve-Coffee-Maker/p/K-Supreme-Plus-Single-Serve-Coffee-Maker
- keurig.com/c/coffeemakers101
- dam.keurig.com/content/dam/public-assets/support/kca/pdf/KSupremePlus_UCGuide_E_601.pdf
- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keurig
- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keurig_Dr_Pepper
- amazon.com/dp/B08NQ3495F
- topoffmycoffee.com/best-keurig-coffee-maker/
- topoffmycoffee.com/k-supreme-plus-vs-smart/
- news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50018826
- news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34315220
Alternatives
You might also like.
Community favorite
Hario
V60 Ceramic Coffee Dripper 02
8.7Excellent
The pour-over benchmark: a handmade porcelain cone with spiral ribs and an open bottom that rewards good technique.
Brewers3$30.50
Cult favorite
Moccamaster
KBGV Select 10-Cup Coffee Maker
8.6Excellent
The SCA-certified Dutch drip brewer: a full 1.25 L pot from two switches, built to be repaired for life, but pricey.
Brewers5$369
Best value
OXO
Brew 8-Cup Coffee Maker
8.5Great
An SCA-certified thermal-carafe drip brewer that handles a single mug or a full pot for about $220.
Brewers3$220